Guides › Comparing truck loans
How to compare two truck loan offers
Two lenders, two quotes, and the lower EMI usually wins. That's often the wrong way to choose. This guide compares three ₹30 lakh truck loan offers on what they really cost and what they do to your monthly cash, and shows how to spot a "flat rate" that is much higher than it looks.
In short
- Compare offers on total cost (all interest plus fees) and on monthly cash. They can point different ways.
- A longer tenure lowers the EMI but can add lakhs of interest.
- A lower rate with a processing fee can cost more than a slightly higher rate without one.
- A flat rate of 6% on a 5-year loan works out to about 10.8% on a reducing balance.
Three example offers for the same ₹30 lakh loan
These are illustrative offers, not real lender quotes. All are reducing-balance loans, where interest is charged only on what you still owe.
| Offer | Rate | Tenure | Processing fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 10% | 5 years | none |
| B | 9.5% | 5 years | 2% (₹60,000) |
| C | 11% | 6 years | none |
Step 1: Work out the EMI and the total cost
EMI = P × r × (1 + r)n ÷ ((1 + r)n − 1), where r = yearly rate ÷ 12 and n = months
| A: EMI ₹63,741 × 60 months − ₹30 lakh | ₹8,24,468 |
| B: EMI ₹63,006: interest ₹7,80,335 + fee ₹60,000 | ₹8,40,335 |
| C: EMI ₹57,102 × 72 months − ₹30 lakh | ₹11,11,361 |
Offer B has the lowest rate, but after the fee it costs ₹15,867 more than A. Offer C has the lowest EMI by far, and costs about ₹2.9 lakh more than A over its life.
Watch out: ask every lender for the full list of charges: processing fee, documentation, insurance bundled into the loan, and foreclosure or part-payment charges. A low rate with heavy charges isn't a low-cost loan.
Step 2: Check what each EMI does to monthly cash
Now use our example truck from the trips-per-month guide. It does 8 trips a month at ₹17,000 contribution each (₹1,36,000), with ₹47,000 of fixed running costs.
| Offer A: ₹1,36,000 − ₹47,000 − ₹63,741 | ₹25,259 |
| Offer B: ₹1,36,000 − ₹47,000 − ₹63,006 | ₹25,994 |
| Offer C: ₹1,36,000 − ₹47,000 − ₹57,102 | ₹31,898 |
Offer C leaves about ₹6,600 more each month, and that can matter a lot in the first year, when a truck is new to its routes and every breakdown hurts. But you pay for that comfort: about ₹2.9 lakh extra in total, plus a sixth year of EMIs on a truck that will be older and needing more repairs.
Step 3: Decide which matters more for you
- If monthly cash is tight (the truck barely covers its EMI, as in our EMI vs profit guide), a longer tenure can be the difference between surviving and missing EMIs. Choose it knowingly, and plan to part-prepay when cash allows, if the lender permits it without heavy charges.
- If cash is comfortable, choose the lowest total cost, usually the shortest tenure at the lowest all-in rate.
- Either way, compare offers at the same tenure first, so the rate and fees are compared fairly. Then decide on the tenure separately.
The flat-rate trap
Some vehicle loans are quoted at a flat rate: interest is charged on the original amount for the whole tenure, even as you repay it. A flat 6% sounds cheap next to 10%. It isn't.
| Interest: ₹30,00,000 × 6% × 5 years | ₹9,00,000 |
| EMI: (₹30,00,000 + ₹9,00,000) ÷ 60 | ₹65,000 |
| Same EMI on a reducing balance means a rate of about | 10.8% |
The "6% flat" loan costs more than Offer A at 10% reducing. Always ask: "What is the reducing-balance rate, and what is the EMI?" If the EMI for the same amount and tenure is higher, the loan is more expensive, whatever the headline rate says.
Run it with your own numbers
Put two or three real loan offers into FleetProfit. It works out each EMI, splits interest and principal, and shows the cash each option leaves you every month, with the working shown on every line.
Open ownership and loansCommon questions
What is the difference between flat and reducing interest rates?
A flat rate charges interest on the original loan amount for the whole tenure. A reducing rate charges interest only on what you still owe, so it falls as you repay. For the same headline number, a flat rate costs much more.
Is a longer loan tenure better for a truck?
It lowers the EMI, which helps monthly cash, but you pay more interest in total and keep paying EMIs on an older truck. Choose it only if the monthly cash really needs it.
What charges should I ask the lender about?
Processing and documentation fees, insurance bundled into the loan, foreclosure and part-payment charges, and late-payment penalties. Ask for the total amount you will repay.